Money as Debt

One of the unfortunate side-effects of the scandal over MPs expenses was that it took people’s minds off that other group of perennial fiddlers, the banks.

The difference is, of course, that whereas MPs expenses amounted to thousands of pounds, bankers bonus’ are measured in the millions. And whereas MP’s perks consisted of such unlikely items as floating duck islands and cleaner moats, the ultimate outcome of the present banking system is nothing less than total domination of the whole world by a few powerful institutions.

Everywhere you go you see the same thing. In the middle of every major city, in every country, there are huge buildings of glass and steel which tower above the city landscape like imperious statements of wealth and power. Invariably these buildings are banks.

How did the banks grow so big and come to dominate our world?

How come we have let them?

The process is insidious. Most money in existence does not consist of the notes and coins we carry about in our pockets, but is in the form of debt to banks. The banks create this money out of thin air. This is the simple and startling fact. The money we owe did not exist until the moment we signed the contract to pay it back.

This is known as Fractional Reserve Banking. Banks do not only lend out money deposited with them by savers, but are legally entitled to lend out many, many times this figure.

Thus banks create money. They create money as debt. They create money as debt and then charge interest on it. Thus our money is already devalued even at the moment it is created, since the amount lent out is always less than the amount which has to be paid back.

This is the cause of inflation and it forces us to borrow even more money to cover the difference. Thus there can never be enough money in the entire world to pay off all the debts owed to the banks, and the banks will, in the end, own everything.

And here’s us worrying about floating duck islands.


5 thoughts on “Money as Debt

  1. Quite! Three points…

    Firstly, interest charged by banks is done through the same mechanism of creating both debt and money so there is (in theory) money somewhere to be able to pay off interest too.

    Secondly and more importantly, if money is to remain as a debt based system then we need to decide who owes that debt. Should it be government, individuals or businesses? Perhaps a balance of all three. The thing we can’t do under the current system is complain about the amount of debt – we are simply complaining about the amount of money there is…

    Thirdly, advocating monetary reform and significant control over the banking system has to be the way to go (and of course it is Green Party policy).


    1. Not quite true as I understand it Stuart (though I admit my brain goes slightly wonky when I try to think these things through). Interest is charged on the debt, which means that more has to be paid back than existed in the first place, meaning that society as a whole is always chasing its debts.

      According to a recent French report, around 60% of France’s debt is illegitimate. Ecuador has estimated that around 70% of its debt is illegitimate. We don’t even know who we owe this money to. If money was borrowed under false pretences, say by a dictator to line his own pockets, and the banks were aware of this, this is illegitimate debt. Under the supposed rules of the free market, the banks have taken a risk and should suffer the consequences, but it is not up to us to repay a bad debt, and we have every right to repudiate it.

      I’m glad to hear that the Green Party are advocating Money Reform. This is, indeed, the way to go. I have particular problems with the party system itself, as political parties become merely machines for getting themselves re-elected and tend to create a false sense of loyalty.


      1. The interest gets debited from the loan account and credited to an income account of the bank so technically there is money created through the charging of interest. Of course, mere mortals such as us will never get our hands on it…


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s