War against a foreign country only happens when the moneyed classes think they are going to profit from it. George Orwell
For the past weeks I’ve been delivering British Legion letters to the people of Whitstable.
You will have seen them. The envelope shows a picture of a bunch of First World War British Tommies, kitted out ready for war, with their helmets and their rifles, smiling and carefree, on their way to the front. It’s obvious that none of them have seen any action as yet or they wouldn’t be smiling. By the end of the war most of them will be dead, wounded or severely traumatised.
Above the picture are the words “Over one million men fell”, and below it, “Not one shall be forgotten.”
How disingenuous this sentiment is. It is obvious that we’ve forgotten them or we wouldn’t still be sending our troops to foreign parts in order for them to kill and be killed.
How many more of the dead must we remember before we realise that war is always the problem, never the solution, and almost invariably based on lies?
The world’s first national propaganda organisation was the Ministry of Information in the UK, created during the First World War in order to mobilise public opinion in favour of the war.
One of its great achievements was in characterising the Germans as barbarians. It called them “the Hun” and, in one famous case, accused them of having bayoneted babies during the invasion of Belgium in 1914. That was a lie.
Later the lie was repeated. In 1990 an anonymous female calling herself Nayirah told the Congressional Human Rights Caucus in the USA that she had seen Iraqi soldiers throw Kuwaiti babies out of incubators, where they would be left on the floor to die. The testimony was used by the President of the United States to justify American involvement in the First Gulf War.
That too turned out to be a lie.
We all remember the Weapons of Mass Destruction in Iraq. Apologists for the Second Gulf War now characterise that as a mistake, saying that everyone agreed that Saddam was hiding weapons. This is another lie. I remember seeing reports at the time clearly debunking the evidence, while Robin Cook, Leader of the House of Commons, resigned saying he did not believe there were any weapons. Later David Kelly came out with talk of the evidence being “sexed-up”.
Both Robin Cook and David Kelly died in mysterious circumstances.
More recently there is evidence that the threatened slaughter of civilians in Benghazi, on which the 2011 No Fly Zone over Libya was based, was also a lie.
Lies, lies and yet more lies.
Now here is the truth. War is profitable. War makes money, for the arms industry, for the weapons manufacturers, for the security services, for the sub-contractors employed to rebuild the country. War is essential for the capitalist economy. It is through war that public money is funnelled into private hands. Without war, all the research and development into the high tech industries couldn’t take place. We’d have no computers, no internet, no digital revolution. War is the means by which public finances can be put at the service of the private economy. It is Military Keynesianism.
Keynesianism argues that a constant injection of public money into the economy is necessary for economic stability. In post-war states, that meant money for infrastructure projects, for hospitals and housing, for the welfare state. Military Keynesianism has no need of such wasteful expenditure. Why put money in the hands of the people? It uses the state machine to siphon the money directly into private hands using security issues as its means. Hence the need to keep us constantly on the alert. Hence the need for lies.
It’s the same people who argue for deregulation and privatisation of our public services who also drum up the hysteria about foreign threats and the need to combat terrorism. You want to know how to stop the threats against us? Stop threatening them. You want to know how to stop terrorism? Stop participating in it.
The last war in Syria was just another in a long line of manufactured threats, and there were a number of notable lies.
One of them was the massacre at Houla. The first time we heard about it was when the media reported that 108 civilians in the village had been killed by shell fire. To illustrate the atrocity the BBC showed a photograph of several rows of dead children wrapped up ready for burial. Except that it quickly emerged that these photographs weren’t from Houla at all, but had been taken in Iraq almost a decade earlier.
‘Somebody is using my images as a propaganda against the Syrian government to prove the massacre’, said photographer Marco Di Lauro, whose photo it was.
Nevertheless the propaganda onslaught continued, for several weeks, suggesting that the Syrian government had been involved in the murder of civilians. It was only later that the truth emerged, in the German newspaper Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, that actually the victims had been pro-government Alawites murdered by the rebels and then used as anti-government propaganda. Needless to say, while the initial reports were front page stories, the later retractions were buried in the small print or not mentioned at all.
After that we had the story of the chemical attack on Ghouta, which I’ve written about here. This was also exposed as a lie.
So next time you hear of a supposed threat from an embattled, weakened and severely impoverished third world nation, remember: War is the mechanism by which our masters control us. It is the means by which we are enslaved.
Harry Patch, Britain’s last fighting Tommy, said of War that it is legalised mass murder.
And while it is legitimate to think of the dead of the two World Wars at this sombre time of remembrance, it is also right to temper our reflections with the knowledge that the justification for most of these wars has been based upon fabrications, and that our soldiers did not die for freedom, or democracy, or any of the other platitudes, but to serve the interests of the wealthy elites.
Like what you read? Please donate as little as £1 to help to keep this site – and independent journalism – alive.
Brilliantly written and if just one more person starts to think rather than simply accept, it will have been worth the effort of writing it..
Thanks Dick. I don’t know how much difference this makes to the world, but it makes me feel better for having written it.
[…] CJ Stone, previously […]
My grandpa lied about his age to join up for WWI,along with many of his peers; he returned alive but paid the price with frequent operations to remove the shrapnel shifting throughout his body. Watching him suffer as I grew up resulted in me arriving at the same conclusion; thank you fro expressing my feelings so eloquently Chrix xx
brilliant – thanks – Remembrance Sunday – now the Queen & her despots are trying to make out its for Iraq and Afghanistan the shysters
Nice article. Very good. Be glad when more and more people start seeing things this way. Was in a group of people about 4 weeks ago, young lad excited because the next day he was going to his army placement. Everyone around was congratulating him etc. I had to bite my tongue because if I said what was on my mind – would probably have been tarred and feathered.
Yes John Connor. I have had graduating secondary school students asking me for my opinion on their eager ambition to join the armed forces….the Dutch marine corps because they were being sent out on ‘police’ duties in Afghanistan. They were difficult conversations. I told him I believed it’s important to follow dreams, but that history shows what Chris points out…the politicians have always been willing to sacrifice the health and life of these eager young chaps.
Chris, I have recently been looking into archery in the warfare of the 20th century. From an archer’s perspective it is interesting to discover that British troops were using longbows and crossbows in the trenches in 1914-1915. But then, looking at the ‘why’, we discovered that the Tommies were woefully ill-equipped. Their government didn’t see the trenches coming . The Germans did, they brought 150 brand new mortars to use as trajectory weapons. The French filled the gap by actively using Napoleonic mortars from museums. The Tommies improvised, they build their own bombs using the jam tins (part of their rations) and built, borrowed or stole longbows and crossbows to launch these bombs with. All kudos to them for their ingenuity, their bravey is astonishing. But their leaders…..Very good article you’ve written here.
[…] well everything you see these days is propaganda in some form, and while people are becoming increasingly aware of the scope and influence of […]